97 Comments
founding

Will being a paid member put me at risk of Rico charges?

Expand full comment

When I first saw the notification for this on my phone I thought this was with Mike Pence

Expand full comment
author

Reason contributor Mike Pence, you mean? https://reason.com/people/mike-pence/

Expand full comment
Aug 25, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

How did I miss that?

Expand full comment

Reason: contributors ranging from Mike Pence to Jonathan Chait & beyond.

Expand full comment
author

Did Chait write for us? Christ.... I did get Ken Layne in there one time (appropriately about Philip K. Dick).

Expand full comment

I think Chait was an editorial assistant circa 93. Jesse Walker knew him from Michigan & I worked with Jesse at the time.

Expand full comment

This is all from memory, but I think that’s the story.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, he & Chait are old chums.

Expand full comment

Mike Pence, host of the podcast Not Even There.

Expand full comment

Same! I was relieved to hear it was Pesca instead.

Expand full comment

I also thought it was Pence, but was honestly disappointed to find out it wasn't! I love Pesca, but could you *imagine* how awkward and fascinating it would be to get these guys in a room with Won't-Dine-With-A-Woman-Who's-Not-His-Wife-Mike-Pence?

Expand full comment

hahaha That's true! Listening to MM tell of his weekend escapades in front of Pence would make my day. I used to work in DC and worked tangentially in that (awful) world of the Christian right who followed that stupid don't dine with women rule. Between that and the "grown men shouldn't be forced to learn from a woman" rule, my career didn't last long there. Making Pence squirm would've been fun revenge for me.

Expand full comment

Happy birthday 🎉 Michael! 72 years young!

Expand full comment
Aug 25, 2023·edited Aug 25, 2023

He looks pretty good for 72 years of hard living!

Expand full comment

In honor of his birthday I’m about to crack open my first Martin Amis novel.

Expand full comment

Follow up from the members only but Oliver Anthony’s comments about Fox using his music for the GOP debate is pretty damn Fifth: “I wrote that song about those people. So for [the candidates] to have to sit there and listen to that, that cracks me up,” he says. “That song has nothing to do with Joe Biden. It’s a lot bigger than Joe Biden. That song was written about the people on that stage — and a lot more, not just them, but definitely them…I see the right trying to characterize me as one of their own and I see the left trying to discredit me, I guess in retaliation.”

Expand full comment
author

Yup. Pretty great.

Expand full comment

I appreciate him more after reading that response. Not that I'm necessarily a fan of the song that much (it's fine but nothing special and honestly a little awkward) but at least he's not just a partisan puppet.

Expand full comment
Aug 28, 2023·edited Aug 30, 2023

The things he is describing align with the Trump base. (Who also don't have much use for the people on stage in the debate, to be fair.) He's mad at inflation, taxes, welfare cheats and pedophile politicians, not the low minimum wage, absence of card-check unionization and failure to forgive Oberlin kids' college debt.

Oliver may not like the fact that his song's protagonist is a Trumpy right winger, but Death of the Author and all that.

Expand full comment

Gonna update my dating profile with cosmopolitan international elite they person doing secret things to manipulate power, resident of Gomorrah, who goes to church every week with 35% of my best friends.

Expand full comment
author

"update"

Expand full comment

Or at least, every Second Sunday.

Expand full comment

I haven’t listened yet (I’m at work), but we know why Not Even Mad, which I like, failed: Heffernan couldn’t bear to be outside her echo chamber and have her ideas challenged. But Pesca and Kirchik are great.

Expand full comment

Sounds like maybe it was coming more from the Kirchik side? I do like him though.

Expand full comment

I’ve listened now. I don’t know. The impression I get, both from what Pesca said here and on the postmortem ep of NEM, was that Kirchik and Heffernan were getting mad, but the latter couldn’t handle online criticism from likeminded lefties. Either way, it’s a shame it didn’t work out.

For a good podcast featuring three people of differing political philosophies getting along, I recommend, if you’re a film lover as I am, Across the Movie Aisle with Sonny Bunch, Alyssa Rosenberg and Peter Suderman.

Expand full comment

I can’t remember if it was the wrap up of NEM or an episode of The Gist, but MP’s in the moment breakdown of the situation put more onus on VH’s failure to cope with both JK’s arguments and criticism from her “side” about not being aggressive enough/participating at all. I can’t really blame MP for going for the “spread & soften” approach a few months removed, though. Diplomacy is wise.

Expand full comment

Kathleen, yes, that was in the NEM epilogue, and MP alludes to it with the lads here, too.

One of the best NEM eps was sans VH, when Dan Savage joined MP and JK. I really enjoyed it. Also the first part of the wrap-up, if I remember correctly, was the intended format but with two different panelists joining MP.

Expand full comment

*liked, I meant to say.

Expand full comment
Aug 25, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

Shabbat shalom to all the Fifdom Theys 🙌🏼 happy birthday Moynihan! 🥳

Expand full comment
Aug 26, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

Had two thoughts from this episode.

1. There's a bar in Chicago called the Tin Lizzie that's decorated with celebrity mug shots, including Larry King. They also do turtle races.

2. Matt made a point about church attendance. Don't know where his numbers came from, but worth noting that church attendance surveys are notoriously unreliable. Social desirability bias makes people over-report how often they go. The effect is particularly strong in the US, to the point where research using time diaries brings the US much more in line with European countries. Although I'd say the fact that the effect is so strong in the US is notable in itself. (PDF) https://www.unil.ch/files/live/sites/issr/files/shared/8._Telechargement/Cours_MA_Chaves_2011/2011_Brenner.pdf

Expand full comment

Yeah I feel like this is something that has really changed in the US over the past 30-40 years. In the 80s/90s there were a lot of people who didn't always go, but people who didn't go at all ever felt a bit of an outlier, and maybe something you even had to hide a bit.

These days the expectation is that people don't go at all, or maybe just a couple times a year, and anything more is surprising. And even people who are fairly religious and go pretty regularly might skip it if the kid has a baseball game or something. When scheduling youth sports, conflicts with church times don't even come up for discussion.

And I am part of an early morning Sunday thing that I am sure initially started at that time so as not to conflict with church, but these days I would be shocked if more than a few of the people there even went to church. Even some of the quite religious people there don't seem to go to church much.

Anyway, just seems like so wild changes in such a short time.

Expand full comment
Aug 26, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

This was a good ep.

Expand full comment

Shots fired @ Chris Hayes 😏

Expand full comment

How does Kmele know his Tesla identifies as black?

Expand full comment
Aug 27, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

Criminally underrated comment

Expand full comment

That's preposterous!

Expand full comment

I've been a fan of both you guys and Mike for awhile so super excited that he's able to be a guest again! I think he fits in well as a fourth man on the mic. I would love a Mike & Michael spin-off riffing on random topics to see who can go the deepest on obscure references

Expand full comment

Name of the podcast: ‘Mic Drop’?

Expand full comment

Perfect. Can't be successful without a good pun name

Expand full comment
Aug 25, 2023·edited Aug 25, 2023

Moynihan and I have the same birthday. That has to be worth something. Happy birthday, Mike!

Expand full comment

Happy birthday! Even cooler, you share the same birthday as Aaron!

Expand full comment

Happy Birthday!🎉

Expand full comment

Tiger Woods mugshot still holds the title IMO

Expand full comment

I am learning Michael and I share the same birthday of Aug 24th!

Expand full comment

Happy belated birthday!

Expand full comment

Sister's is the 27th. Wife's is the 29th. Wife's best friends is the 31st. Guess it was a Happy Thanksgiving in some people's households.

Expand full comment

I really liked Not Even Mad. I found common ground and disagreement with all three. Heffernan was likable but I remember being very annoyed by her more than the others. I think most when she said James Bennett was pushed out for being a BAD EDITOR, which was a novel take. Also, when she was on with Meghan Daum she was clear there were people she would just not talk to, which seemed to contradict the whole purpose of the podcast!

Expand full comment

Same here. This is the same Heffernan who wrote the ridiculous LA Times piece in which she wondered how to behave toward her very friendly, helpful neighbors who happened to be Trump voters, and the laughably hagiographic story on Pete Buttigieg for Wired. Let her stay in her bubble.

Expand full comment